Love and Commitment

New Jersey Therapy and Life Coaching Therapist and Life Coach Voorhees NJ (856) 352-5428 Contact NJTLC

Last week, I met with two couples for the first time at my therapist's office in Voorhees, NJ. They came in on different days, but they could have been the same couple. Both were openly angry. Both talked over each other, blamed each other, and used a tone of voice I wouldn't want used on me. The disrespect wasn't hidden. It was the whole show.

Couples usually don't come in this close to the end of the line. Most arrive with disagreements and bad communication habits, but they're still basically on the same team. The fact that they booked the appointment tells me both people want the relationship to work. With these two couples, I wasn't so sure. I'd have bet against both of them.

The First Couple

The first couple looked like they were in serious trouble. He was quiet, and I felt like he didn't really know why he was sitting in my office. His fiancée was angry from the first minute to the last, and she disrespected him over and over. What she wanted, and what the screaming seemed to be about, was for him to change.

She wanted him to open up and share more instead of staying quiet. I also learned she'd been sent to anger management counseling twice in her life, which, after watching the session, didn't surprise me. Meanwhile, he couldn't figure out what she actually wanted him to do differently. The more she yelled, the more humiliated he got, and the quieter he became. We got almost nothing done. When they left, I was sure I'd never see them again.

The Second Couple

The second couple communicated a little better than the first, but only a little. They'd been together ten years and had just gotten married, and now they were fighting most of the time. She felt disrespected by her new husband. He said he wasn't sure how he could keep going, because she kept blaming him for things he either didn't understand or couldn't control. I scheduled a second appointment for each couple, one right after the other, both for today.

Hope?

This morning, the wife from Couple 2 called to cancel. She was so mad at her husband she didn't see the point of coming in. I had Couple 1 on the books for 8 PM and fully expected an empty office.

Then both couples showed up. Couple 1 walked in at 8 on the dot. And the wife from Couple 2, who'd told me a few hours earlier she wasn't coming, walked in right next to her husband.

This week, it was Couple 2's turn to behave badly. They ripped into each other, blamed each other, and both of them threatened divorce at some point. Still, we made progress. They agreed to stop picking at each other and spitting venom. They agreed that the word "divorce" was off the table unless one of them was serious and ready to act on it. They walked in hating each other and walked out committed to a few tools for saving their marriage.

Surprised

Because Couple 1 had treated each other so badly the first time, I started by meeting with each of them alone for about ten minutes. I had one question. Given how you acted toward each other last week, are you really committed to fixing this, or is it already over? Both of them, separately, told me the same thing. They loved each other and were absolutely committed to the relationship.

I was surprised both times. Love survives even when it looks impossible. Who knew love and commitment were that tough?

What the Anger Was Really Telling Me

Here's what I missed that first week. Anger that loud usually isn't a sign that someone has stopped caring. More often, it's a sign that they care a great deal and have run out of ways to say it. Nobody screams at a person they've already given up on. They go quiet. They get polite. They start sleeping on the couch and looking at apartments online. Screaming is what people do when they still want something from each other and can't get it.

The woman in Couple 1 wasn't yelling because she wanted out. She was yelling because she wanted in. She wanted her fiancé to talk to her, and every time he went quiet, it felt to her like a door closing. His silence wasn't indifference either. It was a man who'd learned that whatever he said would be wrong, so he stopped saying anything. Two people who wanted the same thing, closeness, and were each doing the one thing guaranteed to push it away.

Couple 2 had a different version of the same problem. Ten years together, and getting married raised the stakes. Blame is what fear sounds like when it comes out of a tired person's mouth. She blamed him because she was scared the marriage was already failing. He pulled back because he was scared he'd never be enough. Neither of them said any of that out loud. They said "you always" and "you never" instead.

Why Commitment Is All I Need

So when I ask a couple whether they're committed, I'm not making small talk. It's the one thing I can't give them. I can teach people to argue without cruelty. I can show them how to listen, how to repair after a blowup, and how to ask for what they need instead of attacking. None of it works if one partner has a foot out the door. But if both of them are in, really in, almost everything else can be fixed. To help a couple repair and rebuild a relationship, I only need to know that each partner is committed to the other and that both are committed to making it work.

That's the lesson I took from these two couples, and it's the one I'd want you to take, too. If you and your partner are fighting the way these couples were fighting, don't assume it's over. Loud, ugly fights hurt, but they're not the same as the end. Ask each other one question, privately and honestly: are you still in? If the answer is yes on both sides, you have what you need to start. The rest is work, and it's work I can help with. To learn more, visit Marriage Counselor in Voorhees NJ and Marriage Therapy and Relationship Therapy.